BOSTON, Oct. 16, 2026 — The Red Sox may have the best defensive outfield-and-corner trio in the American League. They also went home after two games in October, outscored 18-2 by the Yankees. Both of those things are true at once, and the tension between them is the story of Craig Breslow’s winter.
On Wednesday, Rawlings named three Red Sox as finalists for the 2026 American League Gold Glove Awards: third baseman Caleb Durbin, center fielder Ceddanne Rafaela and right fielder Wilyer Abreu. For a team that spent much of the last decade hearing about its sloppy defense, that is a real turnaround. It also sharpens an uncomfortable question. If the gloves are this good, why did the season end so fast?
The three finalists, by the numbers
Wilyer Abreu, right field. Abreu has won the last two AL Gold Gloves in right and is chasing a third straight. According to The Boston Globe, his 28 defensive runs saved led every player at every position in both leagues. He also piled up 13 outfield assists, per NESN. The one soft spot in his case is range: the Globe notes he graded at just 2 outs above average, a range-focused Statcast measure. His competition is Houston’s Cam Smith, whom some analysts consider the favorite after he posted 7 outs above average, and Toronto’s Nathan Lukes, who started only 87 games in right.
Ceddanne Rafaela, center field. The 2025 Gold Glove winner was also runner-up for last year’s AL Platinum Glove. This season he led AL center fielders in defensive runs saved (21) and outs above average (16), according to the Globe, and NESN credits him with a league-best eight assists at the position. Texas’ Evan Carter and Cleveland’s Steven Kwan are the other finalists.
Caleb Durbin, third base. In his first season in Boston, Durbin is a first-time finalist. The Globe reports he led AL third basemen with 13 defensive runs saved and 7 outs above average, and he did much of that while playing through a left pinkie injury that required surgery earlier this month. He faces Minnesota’s Brooks Lee and Kansas City’s Nick Loftin.
Winners will be announced on Nov. 1. The vote is weighted 75 percent toward ballots from major league managers and coaches, who cannot vote for their own players, and 25 percent toward advanced defensive metrics.
Why the gloves did not save October
Here is the other half of the ledger. Boston finished 23rd in the majors in runs (689) and 26th in home runs (163), according to Boston.com’s account of the club’s end-of-season press conference. The Wild Card Series in the Bronx was a mismatch: the Yankees outhit the Red Sox 26-7 across two games. Outfielder Roman Anthony, who missed more than 100 regular-season games with a wrist and hand injury, did not play in the series.
That is a strange ending for a team that spent the summer looking like a contender. Boston ripped off a 32-5 stretch in the middle of the season, and the defense was a big reason the pitching held up. But the postseason box scores told a familiar story. Starters Payton Tolle and Sonny Gray each left after 4 2/3 innings with only one run allowed, the bullpen gave the leads away, and the lineup never generated enough to cover for it. Good defense shortens innings. It cannot score runs.
Breslow was blunt about the diagnosis. He said the lineup lacked power and did not take full advantage of Fenway Park, and he named a lineup built for that park as the priority. NESN framed the result as a real dilemma: the obvious fix is to add a slugger, but many of the available bats would weaken a defense that is now one of the club’s identities.
It is worth being clear about what is known and what is speculation. The finalist list, the stats above and Breslow’s comments are on the record. Which hitters Boston will pursue, and whether any defender gets moved to make room, is not. As of Friday there was no confirmed trade, signing or position change.
Boston’s Take
Do not trade the gloves to buy a bat. Defense is the one thing this roster does at an elite level, and it is cheap, young and under team control. Abreu, Rafaela and Durbin turn routine hits into outs every night, which quietly props up a pitching staff that will need all the help it can get. Shipping one of them out for a slugger who costs runs in the field is trading a sure thing for a hope.
The bat belongs at first base or designated hitter. The cleanest path is to add power at the positions where defense matters least. That keeps the outfield intact and puts the money where the lineup is thinnest. A healthy Roman Anthony is, in effect, a free addition too.
Rafaela’s bat is the swing factor. If he can be even a league-average hitter, a Gold Glove center fielder is one of the most valuable players in the sport. Whether that happens is a bigger offseason question than any free-agent rumor.
Root for Durbin on Nov. 1. A first-year player winning at third while playing hurt would say a lot about the kind of roster Breslow has built. Now he has to build the other half.
Red Sox quiz: the Gold Glove finalists
Tap an answer to reveal the explanation. Your score appears at the end.
Talk it over
- Would you trade one of the three Gold Glove finalists if it brought back a proven 30-homer bat?
- Is first base or designated hitter the right place for Boston to add power, or does the lineup need help everywhere?
- How much of the October collapse was the offense, and how much was bullpen and game management?
Sources
Featured image: AI-generated illustration (DeepAI). Boston Made is not affiliated with the Boston Red Sox or Major League Baseball.