smallpox Archives - Boston Made, Inc. | Boston, Massachusetts, USA https://bostonmadeinc.com/tag/smallpox/ News, announcements and stories from Boston Made, Inc. and its companies. Thu, 05 Nov 2026 00:36:24 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://bostonmadeinc.com/brand-kit/fav/bostonmade/favicon-32.png?v=4 smallpox Archives - Boston Made, Inc. | Boston, Massachusetts, USA https://bostonmadeinc.com/tag/smallpox/ 32 32 The Boston Smallpox Wars of 1721: The Experiment That Divided a City https://bostonmadeinc.com/the-boston-smallpox-wars-the-experiment-that-divided-a-city/ Fri, 13 Feb 2026 04:12:08 +0000 https://bostonmade.com/?p=91007 The Boston Smallpox Wars: The Experiment That Divided a CityWhen smallpox struck Boston in 1721, a minister, an enslaved African man and a self-taught doctor championed inoculation, and the town split over it. The fight produced some of the earliest statistical evidence in American medicine.

The post The Boston Smallpox Wars of 1721: The Experiment That Divided a City appeared first on Boston Made, Inc. | Boston, Massachusetts, USA.

]]>

In the spring of 1721, a ship arriving in Boston Harbor from the West Indies brought more than cargo. Smallpox came ashore, and over the following months it spread through a town of roughly 11,000 people. Before the epidemic burned out, more than half the population would fall ill, and Boston would be consumed by one of the fiercest public arguments in its colonial history: whether a strange and frightening procedure called inoculation could save lives or would only spread death faster.

The debate set ministers against physicians, newspapers against the clergy and neighbors against neighbors. It also produced something new in America: a careful count of who lived and who died, used to make a medical argument.

A Disease Boston Knew Too Well

Smallpox was a familiar terror in colonial New England. It had struck Boston repeatedly in the seventeenth century, and the town had developed rough public-health tools, such as quarantining arriving ships and isolating the sick. In 1721 those measures failed. Once cases appeared in town, residents who could afford to leave fled to the countryside, and the selectmen struggled to track the infection house by house.

Smallpox killed a large share of those it infected, and survivors were often scarred or blinded. But people had long noticed one crucial fact: anyone who survived smallpox did not catch it again.

Onesimus and Cotton Mather

The idea that would divide Boston came partly from a man whose voice is rarely recorded in colonial documents. Onesimus was an enslaved African man who had been given to the Puritan minister Cotton Mather by members of his congregation in 1706. When Mather asked whether he had ever had smallpox, Onesimus described a practice from his homeland: material from a smallpox sore was deliberately introduced into a small cut on a healthy person, who then usually suffered a milder case and gained lifelong protection.

Mather, an intensely curious man who corresponded with scientists in London, later read reports published by the Royal Society describing the same technique as practiced in the Ottoman Empire. Other Africans in Boston confirmed that the method was known to them. When the epidemic arrived in 1721, Mather wrote to the town’s physicians urging them to try it.

Zabdiel Boylston Takes the Risk

Almost every medical practitioner in Boston refused. The one who agreed was Zabdiel Boylston, a respected local surgeon and apothecary who had trained through apprenticeship rather than university study. In late June 1721, Boylston inoculated his own young son and two enslaved members of his household. All three survived. Over the following months he inoculated more people, eventually numbering in the hundreds.

It was a genuine gamble. Inoculated patients developed real smallpox, usually mild but occasionally fatal, and they could infect others while sick. Critics argued, with some reason, that inoculating people in the middle of an epidemic might feed the outbreak rather than slow it.

The Opposition

The leading opponent was William Douglass, a Scottish-born physician who was among the very few practitioners in Boston holding a university medical degree. Douglass attacked inoculation as untested and reckless, and he was openly contemptuous of a minister and a surgeon without a medical degree promoting it on the word of enslaved Africans, an argument that mixed legitimate scientific caution with the racial prejudice of the era.

Many townspeople agreed with Douglass, and some went further, arguing that deliberately giving someone a disease interfered with divine providence. Town officials, worried about the spread of infection, tried to discourage the practice. Boylston faced threats severe enough that he reportedly had to hide for a time.

A Newspaper War

The controversy spilled into Boston’s young press. In August 1721, James Franklin launched a new paper, the New-England Courant, which became a platform for inoculation’s critics and for sharp satire aimed at the Mathers and the clergy. The Courant‘s willingness to challenge established authority made it a landmark in American journalism, and it later published the early anonymous essays of James’s teenage apprentice and younger brother, Benjamin Franklin.

The ministers, for their part, published pamphlets defending inoculation. Several of Boston’s leading clergy, including Cotton Mather’s father, Increase Mather, supported the practice. The result was a strange reversal of the usual expectation: in this fight, the clergy stood with the experimental method while the town’s most credentialed physician led the opposition.

The Bomb Through the Window

The anger turned dangerous in November 1721. Someone threw a lit grenade, or crude bomb, through a window of Cotton Mather’s house, where a relative was recovering from inoculation. The fuse came loose and the device failed to explode. Attached to it was a threatening note; Mather recorded its message, which cursed him and mocked his support for inoculation. No one was ever held responsible.

Counting the Dead

What ultimately made the Boston episode historically important was the evidence it produced. Mather and Boylston kept track of outcomes, and Boylston later published a detailed account in London. The commonly cited figures from the epidemic run roughly like this:

  • Close to 6,000 Boston residents caught smallpox naturally during the epidemic.
  • About 844 deaths were recorded, a death rate of roughly one in seven among those infected naturally.
  • Of the roughly 240 people Boylston and a few others inoculated, about six died, a rate closer to one in forty.

The comparison was not a modern controlled trial. Those inoculated were not chosen at random, and record-keeping was imperfect. Still, the gap was large, and the method of comparing death rates between groups was an early and influential use of numbers to settle a medical question. Boylston traveled to England, presented his results and was elected a Fellow of the Royal Society.

What Came After

Inoculation remained controversial in Boston for decades, but it gradually gained acceptance during later epidemics, and special inoculation hospitals operated in and around the town in the eighteenth century. During the Revolution, smallpox threatened the Continental Army, and George Washington eventually ordered troops inoculated.

The older method was eventually replaced by vaccination, which Edward Jenner developed in England in the 1790s using cowpox, a far safer approach. Benjamin Waterhouse, a Harvard professor, was among the first to promote vaccination in the United States around 1800. Smallpox itself was declared eradicated worldwide in 1980, the end point of a story in which Boston’s frightened summer of 1721 played an early part.

Remembering Onesimus

For many years, histories credited Mather and Boylston alone. More recent accounts have restored Onesimus to the center of the story, recognizing that knowledge carried across the Atlantic by enslaved Africans helped introduce one of the most consequential medical ideas in colonial America. His contribution is a reminder that the Boston of 1721 was built in part by people whose expertise was taken while their freedom was denied.

Boston’s smallpox fight shows a city learning, painfully and imperfectly, to test new ideas against evidence. That willingness to argue, measure and change course remains one of the ways Boston keeps reinventing itself.

Quick check: Who first described smallpox inoculation to Cotton Mather?

  1. William Douglass, the university-trained physician
  2. Onesimus, an enslaved African man in Mather’s household
  3. James Franklin, publisher of the New-England Courant
Show answer

B. Onesimus explained the practice from his homeland, and Mather later found matching reports from the Royal Society.

The post The Boston Smallpox Wars of 1721: The Experiment That Divided a City appeared first on Boston Made, Inc. | Boston, Massachusetts, USA.

]]>
91007