maritime history Archives - Boston Made, Inc. | Boston, Massachusetts, USA https://bostonmadeinc.com/tag/maritime-history/ News, announcements and stories from Boston Made, Inc. and its companies. Thu, 05 Nov 2026 00:36:14 +0000 en-US hourly 1 https://bostonmadeinc.com/brand-kit/fav/bostonmade/favicon-32.png?v=4 maritime history Archives - Boston Made, Inc. | Boston, Massachusetts, USA https://bostonmadeinc.com/tag/maritime-history/ 32 32 Pirates, Privateers & the Dangerous Waters of Colonial Boston https://bostonmadeinc.com/pirates-privateers-the-dangerous-waters-of-colonial-boston/ Thu, 12 Feb 2026 01:20:58 +0000 https://bostonmade.com/?p=91006 Pirates, Privateers & the Dangerous Waters of Colonial BostonIn colonial Boston the line between lawful privateer and hanged pirate could be thin. This feature covers Captain Kidd's arrest, the Whydah survivors' trial, Cotton Mather's gallows sermons and the town's long record of commerce raiding.

The post Pirates, Privateers & the Dangerous Waters of Colonial Boston appeared first on Boston Made, Inc. | Boston, Massachusetts, USA.

]]>

Colonial Boston lived by the sea, and the sea was not always safe. Merchant ships leaving Long Wharf could meet storms, enemy warships or armed crews looking for plunder. Boston was a target for pirates and also a place where they were tried and executed. It was also a base for privateers, private ships licensed to attack enemy commerce in wartime. Colonists understood that the difference between a privateer and a pirate was often just a piece of paper.

Pirate or Privateer?

A privateer carried a government commission, called a letter of marque, that allowed it to capture enemy merchant ships in wartime. Captured ships and cargo were taken to an admiralty court, condemned as lawful prizes and sold, and the owners and crew shared the money. A pirate had no commission and attacked any ship, from any nation, at any time. Both were dangerous, but the law treated them very differently.

The trouble was that wars ended and commissions expired. Crews trained in commerce raiding sometimes kept going after the peace was signed. Many of the men executed for piracy in the early 1700s had started as privateers or navy sailors. That was the background to some of Boston’s most famous trials.

Captain Kidd’s Last Stop

The best-known pirate connected with Boston is William Kidd. He was a Scottish-born sea captain who had lived in New York. In 1696 he sailed with a commission to hunt pirates in the Indian Ocean, backed by powerful investors including Richard Coote, Earl of Bellomont, who soon became governor of Massachusetts, New York and New Hampshire. Kidd’s voyage went wrong. He took ships that his accusers said were not lawful prizes, most famously the Quedagh Merchant, and he was declared a pirate.

When Kidd returned to American waters in 1699 he hoped Bellomont would protect him. Instead, the governor had him arrested in Boston that July. Kidd was held in the town jail and then sent to London, where he was tried and hanged in 1701. Legends about buried Kidd treasure along the New England coast have lasted ever since, though very little of his loot was ever found.

Gallows by the Harbor

Boston held some of the largest pirate trials in colonial America under special admiralty courts. Executions usually took place near the waterfront, often on the tidal flats, so that sailors and townspeople could see them. Puritan ministers, especially Cotton Mather, preached to the condemned and published their sermons as warnings.

  • John Quelch (1704): Quelch and his crew took over a privateer and seized Portuguese ships at a time when England and Portugal were allies. Quelch and several crewmen were hanged in Boston in June 1704.
  • The Whydah survivors (1717): In April 1717 the pirate ship Whydah, commanded by Samuel Bellamy, wrecked in a storm off Cape Cod, and most of the crew drowned. Survivors from the wreck and from a captured vessel were tried in Boston. Several were hanged that November and others were acquitted. The wreck was found off Wellfleet in the 1980s, and objects recovered from it have helped historians understand pirate life.
  • William Fly (1726): Fly led a mutiny and a short spree of piracy before he was captured. He was hanged in Boston in 1726, and Mather again took part. Fly’s body was then hung in chains on an island in the harbor as a warning to passing sailors.

Privateering as Patriotic Business

During the long series of imperial wars between Britain and France in 1689–1763, privateering was normal, legal business in Boston. Merchants bought shares in armed vessels much as they bought shares in trading voyages. A successful cruise could make investors and crews rich. An unsuccessful one could lose the ship and the men. Massachusetts ships and men also served in larger operations, such as the 1745 expedition that captured the French fortress of Louisbourg on Cape Breton Island.

The American Revolution expanded privateering greatly. The Continental Navy was small, so Massachusetts and the Continental Congress issued many commissions to private vessels. Ships from Boston, Salem, Beverly, Newburyport and other ports captured British merchant ships and supplies. The work was risky, and captured privateer crews could end up in British prison ships. But prize money drew many sailors, and privateers did real damage to British shipping.

Dangers Beyond the Black Flag

Pirates were only one danger. Colonial sailors also faced:

  • Weather and wrecks: The coast from Cape Cod to Cape Ann was full of shoals and ledges. Boston Light was built on Little Brewster Island in 1716 partly to cut down on wrecks.
  • Impressment: Royal Navy press gangs sometimes forced colonial seamen into service. In 1747 a sweep of Boston’s waterfront set off several days of rioting.
  • Enemy navies: In wartime, French and Spanish warships and privateers hunted New England merchant ships just as Boston’s privateers hunted theirs.
  • Disease: Long voyages to the West Indies and beyond exposed crews to illnesses that often killed more sailors than battles did.

Separating Legend From Record

Pirate stories pick up exaggerations quickly. Tales of treasure buried on Harbor Islands, haunted ledges and secret tunnels are part of local folklore, but few of them are supported by evidence. The documented record of trials, sermons, court papers, ship registers and the archaeology of the Whydah is detailed enough. It shows a port that depended on the sea and worked hard to police it, and that often benefited when its own captains raided enemy ships.

A Port That Keeps Changing

The harbor where pirates were once hanged now has ferries, research vessels and waterfront parks. Boston turned its working waterfront into something new and kept the stories, which is typical of how the city keeps reinventing itself.

Quick check: What legally separated a privateer from a pirate in the colonial era?

  1. A government commission, or letter of marque, to attack enemy ships in wartime
  2. Flying a black flag
  3. Sailing only in the Atlantic
Show answer

A. A letter of marque allowed privateers to capture enemy shipping in wartime, and their prizes had to be judged in an admiralty court. Pirates had no such authority.

The post Pirates, Privateers & the Dangerous Waters of Colonial Boston appeared first on Boston Made, Inc. | Boston, Massachusetts, USA.

]]>
91006